HIGHLY DEBATABLE

-1

Reservation to some extent is ok but above 30% and that too seats going vacant in prestigious institutes like IITs is not acceptable.

From my side it is +1.

well celes ,,, then reservation shud be done on the basis of annual income in the family.... not on the basis of caste and tribe as it hapens...

first let the system change,,, then i will vote FOR reservation ..

but for now,,, since in JEE2009 the system wont change ...
so +1 from me..

and celes,,, do you think each and every ST man in this country are
so poor that they dun have net facility and all...

u cant even say it is maximum of them...

so reservation shud be done in such a way so that it benefits the ppl who worth it ..
n, also dun harm others ....

varna aisa na ho ki...

after 10 years ... we will have reservations ...
i mean reservation for general candidates :P

yup celstine right on the money. good one cele .
but instead of that . KVPY stuff does help . but one sickening aspect of this thing is that most IITians end up doing an MBA . they don't do justice to the country .as far as I know the govt spends abt a lakh per year per student for their education even after you've paid your fees . in the 70's or 60's I don't know, the fee was 200 Rs. I think ,almost free . so imagine how much the govt spends and one ends up doing and MBA which is totally different . so it's a waste of money . they should atleast have some sense to give back to the nation . if that's fulfilled then it's fine else a waste even if your from GM or reservation . really deserving students should be given a chance . the creamy layer thing is bullshit according to me.

and all this is bcoz of corrupt officials not at the national level . Dr.Manmohan Singh's qualifications are many . he's very good.

it's at the root where we're very bad . state level . we should try to get rid of it. by this I mean every citizen , even we can contribute if possible. anyways long talk . sorry :P

Why is this posted in Humour/Fun......??

ya playpower ur correct!!!!!!!!

i too agree wid u sky....coz they r d ones who really need it........

ya me too voting for 1 , i feel it should be for the weaker , totally destressed and almost financially deprived society of india....who should be given reservation.... .. . .. yeah sky it was an Ambedkar project of da plan... and its still extending which i fell isnt FAIR at all[2]

sky is correct ! govt thinks reservation wud do but mr arjun singh dun even bother to visit slums and work for upliftment above all i am not sure whether it is cent percent true but arjun singh is even thinking of reservation of alumni of iit i just read that in a daily few days back ! yes physically punished r the real one's to get reservation or else drain of brain for our country is a prophesy and anti reservation a protest !

bottomline my vote is 1

WEAK???

who weak ???

it was supposed to be effective only for 2 five yr plans i think... [i dun remmber exactly] ... and now it became an eternal thing...

i think reservation should be there for physically challenged ppl ONLY .

bcoz they fight a LOT even to do simple works... reservation should be for them...

-1

reservation essential for weaker sections of society to come up

but it should be done with care so that those not need it dont get it