Most of us aren't happy with JEE-2010 and the way it was conducted?Can we do something?Can we have a re-exam?
those in support of a re-exam do reply here............
1I think we cannot have a say about the pattern or the difficulty of the paper at all...
thats why in all my posts here I was pointing out only the errors in the management and their carelessness even when it is such a reputed exam.
any of the guys if you are worried about the difficulty or the pattern ...
forget it because if it was difficult for you so it was for everyone.
1@ Philip
ab mera tumahre se haath milane ke mann kar raha hai
:)
1but iit doesnt allow two drops
i was thinking wether this is possible
after 10th can a guy drop a year and prepare 3 years for jee
3rd year
he will write jee along with boards and then also if the result is not satisfactory drop another yer and come with flying colors
?
1@akshay : but I still hope they do something......
as gaurav bhaiyya said there were 30 % who didnt know at all about the ors error. That one could be disastrous.
and also they should find some way out for compensating the unclarity of instructions
1@ raja and @ akhay..YOU CANT SIMPLY BLAME THE FACT THAT THE PAPERS DIDNT CHECK the true conceptual ability...its true but just think of it as a different pattern...
as far as clarity is concerned..YES VERY TRUE..THE INSTRUCTIONS WERE NOT AT ALL CLEAR...
1Bhaiyyon aur beheno, set this discussion aside for a few days and prepare for AIEEE. That is going to benefit you more.[1]
1@ nishant sir - maths paper had been difficult no dbt, but never bfore in mcq they asked so tuff qsns. This time, maths paper was above the stds JEE had set in the last 3-4 yrs. They never asked such qsns, and querty bhaiya is correct, I completely agree with him, they shud have atleast given some more space for us to do some ruff work, that would've eased a lot of things.
At the end of the day, say whatever u like, but the raw fact still remains the same, what remains the difference between fiitjee and iit, if they set mo qsns in the paper as mcq?
mai to fiitjee ko gaali deta tha, but I feel they were better in the same, at least fiitjee consistently set such qsns - but this is the first time I've seen IIT doing this!!!
Compare 2008,2009 and 2010 qsns, and then tell me where was maths tuffest.
I cud solve 90% of the maths portion of 2008 and almost 98% of 2009 - but even if I sit now at the cosiness of my own sweet home with the JEE 2010 paper, trying to solve it, I can't proceed with more than 60%.
And as Querty put it, JEE never was so mugging-based!
Whatever u may say nishantsir, u must admit 1 thing, and that is this IIT exam as the worst of the lot.....It is easy for u to say ""What is the fuss if there are a couple of olympiad type problems.. (they are very much in the syllabus)"""....I am saying what of the aspirants in the xam hall - those summations were quite doable, if u had accuarte space - there was hardly any space for rough work!!!
So let me tell u - what is the fuss if 1-page long solution-wala qsns were set in the qsn paper - there will be no fuss if u provide us the space to tackle them!!!
At the end of the day, u have to accept 1 thing and that is this yrs JEE was the 1st of its kind!
1Thik hai yaar, Raja, I understand your frustation...but why cry now? Isn't it better to look ahead? Bhai, try to chill and move ahead to your next paper. Usko phod do[1]
1After all just tell me, if IIT was so much justififed in setting this qsn paper - then why is there so much fuss around 4 a re-test and court cases etc this yr....never bfore this was done.....
That speaks of itself!
With a bizarre marking system overboard, nishant si, put urself just once in our position - chalo mai maan leta hoon ki galat baat kar raha hun, baki to sab mere tara galaat nehi hai! Don't call all of us fools! It's not 4 sake all of us are unhappy with iit, there are strong reasons for the same! [72]
1guruji, u know 2 yrs of hard work goes in vain in just 6 hrs, that's my frustration!
I can't enter my study, the fiitjee books on my shelf are bringing tears in my eyes!
1and asish, what was dat - I had known IIT sums were nmicely solvable (at least till 2009) by nice methods and not simply by putting options!!! this is why I'm shocked with this yrs JEE!
24@raja...share smae concerns as u...but nthing can be done unfortunately...
as sir said...the only situation in which re exam takes palce is a court order...and for court order to come,a case must be filed..and that is a million dollar ques....
its like who will bell the cat ???
though its frustrating to see injustice...but u have to take it as harsh reality..
and btw u r feelling pain of 2 yrs....think abt me..i ahve worked for 3 yrs.. [2][17]...but we have to move on [1]
math was tuff...but by trying again yesterday found that it was ill preperad as sir said and not tuff as thought earlier....i am crying becoz i went about it without any plan...but as saying goes...experince is a tuff teacher [1]
1let th paper be tough..!! its for everyone...
but gime some space...give me some clarity....give me sum instrauctions to tackle he papaer once again!!!
lol
yaar.....wht abt those poor guys who lost time in the MTHEMATICS PHYSICS BLUNDER!!!!
23chalo no problem if the maths is tough , if we are good enough then we will solve it ,
ARE LEKIN JAGAAA to do , if u wanted then 1000 kya 2000 le lete application form ke ,
i solved 4 ques of maths , then rubbed the rough work , and again tried oder 4 , again did the rubbing , and then i got frustated and left maths for physics , wich turned out to be just formulae type !!!
aur fir maths karne ko time hi nai mila .
Actually i never felt like doing maths rough work on that paper , even though maths is the subject that i love most [2] [2]
1But my top 2 subjects in which I had expected most were maths and physics - in maths with no space to try - tell me how it itches!
Feeling like murdering the......council members.
1BLUNDER after BLUNDER
here is another one
" Rajiv Kumar, professor, IIT-Kharagpur pointed out that the translation of Hindi version of paper II said something else. It said, "For each question in section IV, three marks are awarded if the bubble corresponding to the correct answer is darkened, and zero if no bubble is darkened. No negative marks will be awarded for this section."
source:http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Major-error-in-Hindi-version-of-IIT-paper/articleshow/5804808.cms
moreover
"An email question sent to T S Natarajan of IIT-Madras who was involved in this year's JEE did not evince any reply. Even his phone was switched off.".......lol(dar gaya)
49hehehe!!! darna hi chahiye!!!
na jane woh kya kar raha tha duty hours ke waqt ki itni kam galatiya huwi!!! [3][3][3]
neways!! good bye t iit!!
1thanx - a 100 times to rajeev sir 4 bringing out the true face of the so-called most reputed college of india.....woo to iit.
1there is no way out for them except a re exam ...
i attempted question in section 2 and 4 in phy and chem .. i marked what it appeared to be the correct option to me...
by doing that .. i didnt had much time to attempt maths section ... i did only 4 question of maths section ...
what i heard frm other students of my centre , most of them said that .. they marked all options in section 2 , and they attemted much more question in maths section than me ..
today i read in newspaper that the the paper printed in hindi for students also had mistakes .. 8 marks questions (match the columns) in there paper were just of 4 marks..
i believ that by not conducting re -examination or by taking any other measure they will be doing injustice to many students who have spent a lot of money in coaching and lot of time , most importantly their hardwork.
1and then the ppl ask why students in India commit suicide ... becoz these students tend to know frm there experience that if they want to acheive some thing by walking on right path ,they will never gonna acheive it ... they will fall on their face in this attempt..
1do they have ne other options???
see 1stly they hvnt gvn d instructions properly... so now if they come with the idea that all dose who have marked all the options will get a zero, then it will be naturally unwelcome by those students who have marked all the options since no such instructions were given.
and again, if they get the idea that they will gv full marks to them marking all options, then the students who hvnt marked it will blv its a cheating on their part as ppl marking all optns will get 45...n ppls not marks all options vl lose out a large proportion of marks (if not full)...actually its a cheating on both the parts.
iit searches for intelligent minds...now its time for iit 2 get intelligent and come up wid something acceptable for everyone.
23but abhirup , they obviously will giv zero to those who hav marked even a single option wrong ,
those who deliberately marked all options , are obviously cheating , bcz they are trying to misuse that partial mks system ,
btw in any exam , we get mks only for correct answers right ?
even b4 partial mks system came in , eg in 09 ,
we still had multiple ans correct questions , where if n e 1 option of ours is wrong then we get -1 , remem ?
1ppl who marked all options thinking that they will get marks as there is no negative marking,wat were they thinking.I mean c mon,IIT ppl are not fools there giving u marks for free
It was but obvious that u won't be given marks like that
1@ raja. I feel even more frustated coz I wasted 3 years for this. But...kya kar saktein hain?
1ya...dt shud hv been d rule and it shud hv been stated clearly....i hope so the ppl who tried 2 fool wid iit wont b gvn ne marks...
341I just get the feeling that some diktat from the ministry would have caused some last minute changes in the paper. Otherwise so many blunders in such a high profile exam is baffling.
