341
Hari Shankar
·2009-08-30 22:13:00
By minimum I take it you mean a numerical value and also you dont mean a lower bound.
Note that f(0,0,0) = 0
Now if the minimum m = f(p,q,r)
Suppose m>0, then for |k|>1 f(p/k, q/k, r/k) = 1/k4 f(p,q,r) = m/k4<m
Similarly if m<0, we choose |k|>1 and consider f(pk,qk,rk) and exhibit a lower minimum contradicting the fact that m is the minimum value
Hence m = 0
66
kaymant
·2009-08-30 22:31:45
Those arguments also apply if you replace that factor of 4/7 to something else like 1000....
66
kaymant
·2009-08-30 22:32:16
in fact the factor 4/7 is quite strict.
341
Hari Shankar
·2009-08-30 22:35:32
That's why I want to know if there's an expression on the RHS like some f(a,b,c)?
66
kaymant
·2009-08-30 22:58:33
This was one of olympiads postal coaching of last month and the problem statement is exactly what soumik has written.
11
Mani Pal Singh
·2009-08-30 23:03:38
Is Diophantine equation in Olympiads [5]
341
Hari Shankar
·2009-08-30 23:12:47
hmm, i've got to check if it is bounded below
341
Hari Shankar
·2009-08-30 23:49:13
Well I have just seen the solution for your 2nd problem in a book. It is, as you said, a tough one. I dont think I should give the source, since the olympiad aspirants are supposed to have a crack at it. But like the 1st problem it seemed like I have seen it somewhere, which seems to be the trend for our olympiad and JEE coaching - the trainers are smug with the solutions in their pockets, ready to be drawn out the moment a student asks them. No real training takes place this way. This is, of course, just my opinion.
341
Hari Shankar
·2009-08-30 23:54:37
Ah! I have got very good at detective work - i have tracked down the 1st problem too, again from a well known source. So much for original problem setting and solving!
66
kaymant
·2009-08-31 00:05:57
hmm...so these are copied too... lets hope the students at least are honestly doing them..
341
Hari Shankar
·2009-08-31 00:33:17
most of them tend to be like this. Even some INMO probs I have seen are from old Hungarian competitions.