A nice question

1)prove that (2+√5)1/3 + (2-√5)1/3 is rational.

2)Let a,b,c be distinct real numbers.prove that (a-b)1/3+ (b-c)1/3+ (c-a)1/3≠0

16 Answers

1
champ ·

2)
WLOG,a>b>c

so, a-b>0
b-c>0
c-a<0

that implies, (c-a)1/3 is imaginary whereas other 2 expressions are real.

so,sum of real and imaginary number can never be zero(a,b,c distinct)

1
Shankar C ·

nice explanation....

21
Shubhodip ·

@ champ

u made big mistake.. (-8)1/3 = -2 not imaginary

21
Shubhodip ·

both of them are based on single concept

21
Shubhodip ·

Adding one more.

prove the AM-GM inequality for 3 terms ie x3 + y3 + z3 ≥3xyz

1
champ ·

(-8)1/3=(8)1/3.(-1)1/3

= 2.(-1) or 2.(ω) or 2.(ω2)

1
bindaas ·

@#6

a3 + b3 + c3 = (a + b + c) (a2 + b2 + c2 – ab – bc – ca) + 3abc

6
AKHIL ·

quesn 1 wud be solved by the binomial method
:)

11
Soham Mukherjee ·

let 3(a-b)=x,3(b-c)=y,3(c-a)=z.

then,x3+y3+z3=0

either,(x+y+z)=0
or,x=y=z...[then,it will be a=b=c]
oh...my god..i have proved..
3(a-b)+3(b-c)+3(c-a)=0

11
Soham Mukherjee ·

let,(2+√5)1/3=a,2+√5=a3

(2-√5)1/3=b,2-√5=b3

a3+b3=0
(a+b)3-3ab(a+b)=0...
plz..help me from here..

21
Shubhodip ·

@soham how u got that if x3 + y3 + z3 =0

either x+ y+z =0 or x=y=z ?? this is not correct

21
Shubhodip ·

@ #10 you have a3 + b3 = 4 (not zero)

so (a+b)3 - 3ab(a+b) = 4

or (a+b)3 + 3(a+b) = 4 (ab= -1)

solving the equation for (a+b) we will get (a+b) = 1 hence its proved that the expression is rational.

it can also be solved this way

let x= (2+√5)1/3 + (2-√5)1/3

so x- (2+√5)1/3 - (2-√5)1/3=0

so x3 - 2- √5 - 2 + √5= 3x (2+√5)1/3 (2-√5)1/3

(using the concept that if a+b+c = 0, a3 + b3 +c3 =3abc)

or x3 - 4 = - 3x

or x=1

there is no other real root.

so the expression is a rational number.

36
rahul ·

we know that cuberoot(-ve term) is imaginary...!!

so, how did u take ab = -1 ???

Again,

in ur soln...

i didn't get how u used the concept of a3 + b3 + c3 = 3abc, when a + b + c = 0

Please explain....!! i didn't get..!!

1
EmInEm ·

http://www.targetiit.com/iit-jee-forum/posts/area-volume-18431.html

11
Soham Mukherjee ·

no,3of -ve is not imaginary...
like3-1=-1

other two roots may be ignored...

36
rahul ·

@Soham -> Thanks for clearing my doubt

Well your solution was wonderful and easy to understand....!!

Thanks..!!

Your Answer

Close [X]