pls write a detailed proof
Find all primes p and q ,and even numbers n > 2 , satisfying the equation
pn + pn-1 + · · · + p + 1 = q2 + q + 1.
-
UP 0 DOWN 0 0 3
3 Answers
If p≠q, then we have (p-1)+(p-1)a=2q, for some integer a, that gives p-1=2 or p-1=q, excluding the case when p=2. That gives p>q, implying n≤2
ahh! at last i got it!
with n= 2k, k>1 it is
p(pk+ 1)(pk-1+ ... + p+ 1)= q(q+1)>p(p+1)>30
so q>2
gcd((pk+ 1),Pk-1+ ... + 1) = gcd(pk+1, pk-1p-1)≤ gcd(pk+1, pk-1)≤2
easy to see that p|q+1 (*)
Case 1: q|pk-1+ ...+ 1,(then q≤ pk-1+ ...+ 1) ,so q doesn't divide pk+ 1, i.e gcd(q,pk+1)= 1
easy to see that pk+1|q+1, implying pk+1≤q+1
since gcd(p,pk+1)= 1, p(pk+1)|q+1 from (*)
so p(pk+1)≤q+1≤pk-1+ ...+ p+2
which is wrong since pk+1 -1 + p> pk-1> (pk-1p-1)
Case 2: q| pk+1,(-) so q does not divide pk-1+ ... + p+ 1 i.e gcd(q,pk-1+ ... + p+ 1)= 1
easy to see that pk-1+ ... + p+ 1|q+1
agin gcd(p,pk-1+ ... + p+ 1)= 1
so p(pk-1+ ... + p+ 1)|q+1
it follows that p(pk-1+ ... + p+ 1)≤q+1≤pk+2, from (-)
which means pk+ ...+ p≤pk+ 2
i.e p(pk-2+ ...+ 1)≤2
only possibility p=2,k= 2 giving q= 5
so the only solution is p=2,q=5,n= 4, and its easy to check that this indeed is a solution..
PS. @devil: i dont understand your hint, can you pls put details to it?
@h4hemag: hey is this a real olympiad question ?