For Q4)
As far I have seen, fidelity of ortha effect has always been used to compare the aromatic compound of same composition. i.e, if we are making II in a) more acidic than I, then I should also be of same composition of II.. implies I must also be either p-methyl benzoic acid, or m-methyl benzoic acid.
If Sandipan's answer is followed, then in c) I must have been more basic than II .. see expert's answer here at http://www.goiit.com/posts/list/organic-chemistry-ortho-effect-29780.htm
PS: Yeah, Goiit can be useful sometimes!!..
Do reply the correct explainations.