Physical Chemistry - intensive extensive prorps ( nice 1)

62

Lokesh Verma ·2009-03-12 00:27:45

@eureka.. yes

@abhirup.. we cant even multiply them... so this question woudl be vague then..

i think what it means is simple value wise multiplication..

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

9

Celestine preetham ·2009-03-12 00:59:58

consider PV =nrT

here T P intensive

so PT intense
P/T intense
P + T not defined
VdP/dT + PdV/dt = nr
dP/dT= (nr - PdV/dt) /V = T/P - P/V dV/dt

here the second term is extensive so dP/dT extensive i guess

ne way i ve not solved any problem based on these in iit syllabus

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

MATRIX ·2009-03-12 00:57:39

i think itz not...........d is not correct..........

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

greatvishal swami ·2009-03-12 00:54:42

thnx celes but wat bout opt d is it rite

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

9

Celestine preetham ·2009-03-12 00:52:49

great vishal u r right ans shud be ab

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

9

Celestine preetham ·2009-03-12 00:51:03

from abhis post its clear c is not defined

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

MATRIX ·2009-03-12 00:47:52

hmm........r all the options correct ur saying...........

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

greatvishal swami ·2009-03-12 00:46:53

and i feel really confused [9][9][9][9]

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

13

Ð”Ð²Ò¥Ñ—ÑuÏ now in medical c ·2009-03-12 00:46:07

i feel only ...C

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

24

eureka123 ·2009-03-12 00:44:43

abc...........i still say this........

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

greatvishal swami ·2009-03-12 00:40:35

Q is posted as it is correct ans is wanted

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

62

Lokesh Verma ·2009-03-12 00:37:35

but then i had assumed that this means that we can add them..

still i dont know what the question setter had in his mind..

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

62

Lokesh Verma ·2009-03-12 00:36:13

oops sorry abhi ;P :P :( :P :D :)

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

13

Ð”Ð²Ò¥Ñ—ÑuÏ now in medical c ·2009-03-12 00:34:30

@abhirup.. we cant even multiply them

why can't we multiply them [7]

we can multiply mass and acceleration...na...

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

MATRIX ·2009-03-12 00:28:34

intensive is one which does not depend on the volume we consider extensive depends on the volume!........... Nishant Bhaiyya...hwz it.....[4][4][4]....[9][9][9].........

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

62

Lokesh Verma ·2009-03-11 23:12:51

xy will be intensive

x/y will be intensive

x+y will be intensive

dx/dy will also be intensive....

I think this should be the answer...

why? becasue x is not a function of V
y is not a function of V

and so one..

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

greatvishal swami ·2009-03-12 00:24:43

wat ur telling seems correct
maybe ans is wrong but wat about dx/dy

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

greatvishal swami ·2009-03-12 00:23:40

the Q is frm allen test series

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

13

Ð”Ð²Ò¥Ñ—ÑuÏ now in medical c ·2009-03-12 00:21:23

bhaiyaa...how can we add two variables if they are not identical physical quantities??

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

1

MATRIX ·2009-03-12 00:19:59

intensive is one which does not depend on the volume we consider

extensive depends on the volume!...........

Nishant Bhaiyya...hwz it.....[4][4][4]....[9][9][9].........

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

24

eureka123 ·2009-03-12 00:16:21

sir am i rite with that velocity explaination????

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

62

Lokesh Verma ·2009-03-12 00:15:01

vishal lets see this way

x is iindependent of volume..

y is independent of volume

how can x+y depend on volume!! :O

I dont understand the logic!

which book is it from?

UP 0 DOWN 0
Post on FacebookPost anonymously?

24

eureka123 ·2009-03-12 00:06:19

example for c.......
If we add 2 colors ,we get another color which is an intesive property[1]
Same for velocity too..........we have been doing this for 1 year in mechanics[1]