11
Anirudh Narayanan
·2008-12-12 18:35:14
Should we consider it as a cylinder with constant vol and other parameters changing?
11
Anirudh Narayanan
·2008-12-12 18:41:49
Is it dec. at the rate of 0.5 mm/sec?
1
Rohan Ghosh
·2008-12-12 22:00:18
@Aragorn
we cant consider it as a cylinder with constant volume as its volume is constantly increasing (can of oil supply)
so let dV/dt=k
given dr/dt=10-1
when radius is one metre let the thickness=x
then V= π(r)2x
dV/dt=k= π2xrdr/dt + πr2dx/dt
at the moment r=1
dx/dt=-4*10-3
so we will get k
now replace r by 2 and as we know k and dr/dt we will get the answer
11
Anirudh Narayanan
·2008-12-12 22:47:40
I thought all of the oil fell in at once and so it will be a cylinder of constant volume and dec thickness. If oil supply is constant, then why should the thickness decrease? Anyway, what was the final answer u got?
1
dimensions (dimentime)
·2008-12-12 22:55:12
but u will get in terms of x' then how will u proceed???????????/
1
dimensions (dimentime)
·2008-12-12 22:56:11
i think there is some more information required
11
Anirudh Narayanan
·2008-12-12 23:12:35
I've solved it and got the ans as 0.5 mms-1. Information is enough allright but problem is to assume what the oil's movement is.
1
Rohan Ghosh
·2008-12-12 23:35:57
@ dimensions
as we get k
we get dV/dt
and hence we get V=kt
and further we know
dr/dt=10-1
hence r=10-1t
but we know r=2
hence we will get t
and as kt=Ï€r2x
we will get the value of x
and @ aragorn yes it is not mentioned whether the can continues to leak
so i think we will have to wait until aakash responds ..
6
Aakash Sharawat
·2008-12-13 16:36:23
well the correct answer is 0.5mms-1!!!!! congrats aragorn!
11
Anirudh Narayanan
·2008-12-13 16:46:21
Rohan's solution isn't wrong at all u know! See how a question can have two correct answers? What if this comes in Jee? Which ans will be deemed as correct?
1
Rohan Ghosh
·2008-12-13 20:17:14
if o.5 mm/s is right then aakash means to say that volume remains constant ..
11
Anirudh Narayanan
·2008-12-14 03:43:37
That's right. But u're not wrong either!