Doubt....concentric shells..

A conducting spherical shell of rad. R is placed concentrically inside another similar shell of rad. 2R. The inner shell has a charge Q. If it's connected to the outer shell by a coducting wire , find loss in elec.energy .....

(A) zero (B) Q2/(8 \pi \varepsilono R)
(C) Q2/(4 \pi \varepsilono R) (D) Q2/(16 \pi \varepsilono R)

Pls. post soln also. I have a doubt on the soln. given.

3 Answers

1
ANKIT GOYAL ·

treat first inside shell as capacitor and apply find the energy using .5Q*Q/C. Then find the charges after distribution by applying potential on the both surface. Then once again use the capacitor formula for both the shells, then find the diff.

11
rkrish ·

my doubt is that in Ui do we also consider the charge induced on the outer shell ???????????

11
rkrish ·

I didnt understand the soln given (although their ans & mine is the same)

the soln says....

Ui = (1/2) Q2/(4 pi Eo R) -- Q2/(4 pi Eo (2R) ) + (1/2) (-Q)2/(4 pi Eo (2R) ) + (1/2) Q2/(4 pi Eo (2R) )
= (1/2) Q2/(4 pi Eo R)

Uf = (1/2) Q2/(4 pi Eo (2R) )

Loss = | Uf - Ui | = Q2/(16 pi Eo R)

what i did was...

Ui = (1/2) Q2/(4 pi Eo R) [ i.e. U = (1/2) Q2/C ; C = 4 pi Eo R ]

Uf = (1/2) Q2/(4 pi Eo (2R) ) [ i.e. U = (1/2) Q2/C ; C = 4 pi Eo (2R) ]

Loss = | Uf - Ui | = Q2/(16 pi Eo R)

Your Answer

Close [X]