2)
The professor is correct in saying the statement.
The situation given is like this
Note that the plate is grounded
Some charge will be induced on the conductor because of the charge. As a result, the infinite plate will also induce field and potential at different points..
since the plate is a conductor and is grounded, the potential of the plate is 0.
charge induced on the conducting plate which is grounded are the same.
Hence we can replace the case of of the conducting plate with that of dipole. Answer will be the same.