29
govind
·2010-03-13 04:27:55
the answer is C..looks like a previous JEE quesdtion...
it's a nice one to confuse the student as here Ga seems to be in +2 oxidation state..but the actual formula is Ga+[GaCl4] - in which one Ga is in +1 oxidation state and the other in +3 oxidation state...
11
SANDIPAN CHAKRABORTY
·2010-03-13 06:38:30
e.c of Fe2+ = d6 system loses an electron to change to stable d5 system (full filled t2g considering that pairing occurs)
e.c of Cr2+ = d4 system so ......
on losing an electron changes to d3 system..(half filled t2g)
now which one is more stable half filled or full filled ???? confused!!!
[2]
29
govind
·2010-03-13 07:10:59
@Sandipan..well i guess we see the reducing character in presence of H2O..i mean aqueous solutions..so pairing will not occur..in case of Fe3+ it will be t2g3 eg2 ..and in case of Cr3+ it will be t2g3..so the second one is more stable....
Cr3+ one is more stable coz it has more negative CFSE as compared to Fe3+
24
eureka123
·2010-03-13 09:15:47
or maybe in simpler words...
Cr can go upto +6 state whereas Fe can go till +3 only...so Cr should be better reducign agent..
24
eureka123
·2010-03-13 09:34:10
okk..end to all debate..i got my ans
oxidn potential
Cr3+ + 3e- = Cr 0.74
Fe2+ + 2e- = Fe 0.41
To tell which is the strongest reducing agent,The bigger the oxidation potential. , the stronger the reducing agent.